Search The Line of Best Fit
Search The Line of Best Fit

J Mascis - Ruby Lounge, Manchester 10/01/15

12 January 2015, 09:30 | Written by Joe Goggins

It’s not hard to understand how the old, corny adage that the best songs sound as good when they’re stripped down to their bare bones is one that could reasonably be applied to J Mascis’ output over the years; the difference between his work as frontman and creative supremo for Dinosaur Jr. and his recent solo material represents an enormous chasm. Both 2011’s Several Shades of Why and last year’s Tied to a Star are gentle affairs, real exercises in sonic restraint, but the opposite is increasingly true of Dinosaur Jr., as anybody who experienced their brutal approach to the volume dial during their I Bet on Sky tour can attest.

Despite enjoying the prestige of being released on Sub Pop, though, you can’t help but sense that there’s a real danger of Mascis’ excellent recent solo albums slipping through the net; tonight’s show is a sell-out, but the consistent chattiness of the crowd suggests that casual Dinosaur Jr. fans make up the majority of the throng. That presents Mascis with a little bit of an early challenge, with “Listen to Me” and “Me Again” - intricate, acoustic pieces - meeting with a reaction that borders on disinterest. It’s not until he then drops Jr. favourite “Little Fury Things”, complete with washed-out, distorted guitar, that he really commands the audience’s attention; that he clearly feels a straight-up acoustic set would be an artistic impossibility is a positive thing, allowing him to include classic Jr. cuts in reinterpreted, but still recognisable, form.

Those unfamiliar with Mascis’ solo releases might be surprised to find that the likes of “Every Morning” and “Drifter” don’t fit with the general preconception that he’s been specialising in woozy, blissed-out acoustic fare; the former is capped with a glorious electric solo, whilst the latter’s rolling riffery almost taps into Americana. A searing Jr. double bill of “Not the Same” and “Out There” meets with the evening’s most fervent reception, but it’s his gorgeous rendition of Mazzy Star’s “Fade into You” that provides the set highlight; it’s meatier than the original, of course, but with the aching sense of vulnerability perfectly preserved.

Mascis is famed for his impenetrability in interviews and his perennially detached air on stage; Jr. diehards, of course, would rush to tell you that this is all part of his charm, but tonight he seems almost aggressively aloof. There’s barely a word spoken to the crowd throughout - perhaps a quick murmur of thanks at the very close - and he chooses to play seated when, in a venue as trickily laid-out as tonight’s, it’s likely to afford only those closest to the front any kind of decent view of the man himself. That’s all well and good, of course, but the setlist doesn’t seem to reflect such a disconnect between Mascis and the fans; there’s plenty of Dinosaur Jr., with “Not You Again” and “Alone” closing the main set. The eagerness to crowd-please that those choices represent suggest that he's by no means out of touch with those in attendance, and that his stilted intercations with the audience aren't simply a stage gimmick - they're quite genuine.

By closing with the group’s now-classic cover of The Cure’s “Just Like Heaven”, he confirms his appetite for awkwardness; it ends, as on record, in abrupt fashion just short of the three-minute mark. He's gone seconds later, with a grunt of farewell, and it’s weirdly reassuring to know that whether he’s troubling eardrums with Lou Barlow and Murph or delivering delicate renditions of carefully-weaved indie folk, he’s still the same J Mascis.

Share article
Email

Get the Best Fit take on the week in music direct to your inbox every Friday

Read next