"Since The Bomb Dropped"
02 October 2009, 13:00
| Written by Andy Johnson
Extradition Order's debut album Since the Bomb Dropped reminds me a bit of the Clash's 1980 triple-album Sandinista! Like that record, the album is hugely varied in style, rough round the edges. Occasionally, the vocals are reminiscent of Mr Strummer's coarse style, too. This is a recklessly ambitious debut which attempts lo-fi acoustic guitars and whistling with synthesisers stuck on the end ('Precious Home'), a plodding, waltz-like tune (closer 'Marriage'), and a semi-progressive song with jucious cyclic piano and organ ('The Wheel').Extradition Order's music occupies a space somewhere along the folk/rock axis, but as I've tried to get across, they move around in that space very freely. This versatility is endearing on one level - but a little frustrating on another, in a sense that Since the Bomb Dropped keeps you thinking that it would be a better album if it reined itself in a little bit more. It's always tempting to feel that way about albums that vary wildly in style (The Beatles, Sandinista!, Know Your Enemy etc) but I think it's obviously easier to get away with it if the varied styles are tempered by consistently strong songwriting. On their debut album, attempting to pull this off is a pretty risky strategy for this band.Unlike a lot of these kinds of albums though, the problem is not consistency. The quality of these decidedly off-kilter songs is fairly consistent, but it's consistently average. Occasionally the odd moment stands out, usually an interesting instrumental turn, but no songs are outstanding. The vocals frequently stray a little to the wrong side of annoying, which can sometimes further limit the appeal of this music. The arrangements and composition sometimes feel a bit haphazard, meaning that the songs rarely achieve the punch that they ought to.Burgeoning with interesting instruments and varied styles, Since the Bomb Dropped is an album which aims high, but is too often hamstrung by its own ambition, hoisted by its own petard. Far from bad, it is instead a listenable, but ultimately fairly forgettable and unremarkable set of songs.Extradition Order on MySpace
Get the Best Fit take on the week in music direct to your inbox every Friday
Read next
Listen
Tabi Gervis renounces settling for less on “Clearly”
Isla Den play with light and shadow on "Until The Sun Dies, All My Love"
Disarme creates an engrossing contemplation on the loneliness of city life with debut single “Change”
Disgusting Sisters strut past critical eyes on the entrancing and witty “Killing It”
Saila makes a truly infectious debut with her new hyper-pop single “So Far”
Adult Leisure vent a universal steam on "Kiss Me Like You Miss Her"
Reviews
Kendrick Lamar
GNX
23 Nov 2024
Father John Misty
Mahashmashana
22 Nov 2024
Kim Deal
Nobody Loves You More
22 Nov 2024
Poppy
Negative Spaces
18 Nov 2024